Coach's Corner · through week 9

Fourth-down decisions

How the Detroit Lions head coach handles fourth down, measured against the whole league and against an empirical go-for-it calculator built from play-by-play.

Fourth-Down Aggression Index

Percentage points above the league go rate after matching on distance, field position and win probability. Clock-forced attempts (fourth quarter, under four minutes, trailing) are excluded.

2026 index

+4.2

5th of 32

Go rate

24%

league 17%

Attempts

11

of 45 decisions

Converted

64%

7 of 11

By season

SeasonIndexRankGo rate
2021+4.45th29% go
2022+7.42nd30% go
2023+11.21st33% go
2024+11.71st29% go
2025+5.03rd26% go
2026+4.25th24% go

2026 league ranking

  1. 1BUF+6.1
  2. 2GB+5.3
  3. 3CAR+5.2
  4. 4PHI+4.9
  5. 5DET+4.2
  6. 6MIA+3.3
  7. 7NE+2.9
  8. 8PIT+2.6
  9. 9JAX+2.3
  10. 10LV+0.9
  11. 11NO+0.9
  12. 12DAL+0.8
  13. 13NYG+0.6
  14. 14LA+0.1
  15. 15CHI+0.1
  16. 16MIN0.0
  17. 17SF-0.4
  18. 18CLE-0.5
  19. 19LAC-0.7
  20. 20CIN-0.9
  21. 21BAL-1.0
  22. 22KC-1.1
  23. 23ATL-2.1
  24. 24TEN-2.1
  25. 25IND-2.2
  26. 26NYJ-2.5
  27. 27SEA-2.8
  28. 28TB-3.2
  29. 29DEN-3.3
  30. 30ARI-4.2
  31. 31HOU-4.4
  32. 32WAS-4.9

Go-For-It Calculator

Set the situation; the calculator scores going for it, punting and kicking.

Fourth and 2 at the opponent's 45, Q3, 8:00 left, tied.

  1. Go for it60.7% conversion rate52.6%
  2. Punt33 yd net punt49.7%
  3. Field goal62 yd kick, 61.5% make rate53.4%

Best option by win probability: field goal. Conversion, kick and punt rates and the win-probability grid are empirical averages from 2021–2026 regular-season play-by-play, not the league's model. Clock run-off and timeouts are ignored.

Fourth-Down Decision Log

Every DET fourth-down decision this season. "Calc" is what the calculator above preferred before the snap; the coach agreed on 36 of 45 unforced calls.

Week 1 vs New Orleans Saints

  1. Q1 13:084th & 4 at the own 24 · tied · Punted, punt 56 ydscalc: punted · go 45% / punt 48% · WPA +3.8
  2. Q2 13:474th & 15 at the own 42 · up 7 · Punted, punt 45 ydscalc: punted · go 68% / punt 71% · WPA +1.6
  3. Q2 09:314th & 16 at the own 32 · up 7 · Punted, punt 56 ydscalc: punted · go 68% / punt 70% · WPA +2.9
  4. Q2 03:214th & 7 at the own 39 · up 7 · Punted, punt 47 ydscalc: punted · go 71% / punt 73% · WPA -1.5
  5. Q3 03:344th & 5 at the own 25 · up 14 · Punted, punt 45 ydscalc: punted · go 96% / punt 96% · WPA -1.7
  6. Q4 13:124th & 3 at the own 45 · up 7 · Punted, punt 31 ydscalc: went for it · go 82% / punt 64% · WPA +1.0
  7. Q4 02:354th & 5 at the NO 5 · up 4 · Field goal, madecalc: field goal · go 87% / punt 77% / fg 89% · WPA +1.5
  8. Q4 00:374th & 1 at the own 44 · tied · Punted, touchbackcalc: went for it · go 53% / punt 50% · WPA -14.0

Week 2 vs Buffalo Bills

  1. Q1 07:164th & 15 at the own 30 · down 7 · Punted, punt 49 ydscalc: punted · go 25% / punt 28% · WPA +1.1
  2. Q1 01:094th & 22 at the own 38 · down 14 · Punted, punt 44 ydscalc: punted · go 26% / punt 29% · WPA -2.2
  3. Q2 01:514th & 18 at the own 31 · down 20 · Punted, punt 62 ydscalc: punted · go 7% / punt 8% · WPA -0.3
  4. Q3 11:404th & 5 at the BUF 40 · down 17 · Went for it, convertedcalc: went for it · go 7% / punt 5% / fg 5% · WPA +3.4
  5. Q4 07:364th & 10 at the own 10 · down 10 · Punted, punt 51 ydscalc: punted · go 3% / punt 4% · WPA -0.4
  6. Q4 02:124th & 18 at the own 24 · down 17 · Went for it, convertedforcedcalc: went for it · go 0% / punt 0% · WPA +0.1

Week 3 vs New York Jets

  1. Q1 08:214th & 17 at the own 48 · tied · Punted, punt 43 ydscalc: punted · go 46% / punt 50% · WPA +0.9
  2. Q1 00:234th & 19 at the own 38 · tied · Punted, punt 42 ydscalc: punted · go 44% / punt 50% · WPA +0.6
  3. Q2 09:384th & 8 at the NYJ 12 · tied · Field goal, madecalc: field goal · go 55% / punt 49% / fg 57% · WPA +1.0
  4. Q2 01:474th & 2 at the NYJ 9 · down 4 · Went for it, convertedcalc: went for it · go 44% / punt 34% / fg 40% · WPA +6.1
  5. Q4 08:374th & 1 at the NYJ 45 · up 8 · Went for it, failedcalc: went for it · go 87% / punt 65% / fg 85% · WPA -6.7

Week 4 vs Carolina Panthers

  1. Q1 12:094th & 12 at the CAR 36 · tied · Field goal, madecalc: field goal · go 51% / punt 48% / fg 54% · WPA +6.7
  2. Q1 05:594th & 6 at the own 15 · up 3 · Punted, punt 47 ydscalc: punted · go 51% / punt 53% · WPA +1.8
  3. Q2 12:414th & 7 at the CAR 25 · down 4 · Field goal, madecalc: field goal · go 41% / punt 35% / fg 47% · WPA +1.0
  4. Q3 06:244th & 6 at the CAR 8 · down 6 · Field goal, madecalc: field goal · go 16% / punt 24% / fg 34% · WPA -3.9
  5. Q4 14:494th & 19 at the CAR 48 · down 10 · Punted, punt 34 ydscalc: punted · go 12% / punt 18% / fg 11% · WPA +0.9
  6. Q4 07:104th & 20 at the CAR 25 · down 13 · Went for it, failedcalc: field goal · go 1% / punt 0% / fg 5% · WPA -2.1
  7. Q4 04:054th & 5 at the CAR 10 · down 13 · Went for it, convertedcalc: field goal · go 1% / punt 0% / fg 6% · WPA +2.8
  8. Q4 01:294th & 13 at the own 10 · down 6 · Went for it, failedforcedcalc: went for it · go 5% / punt 5% · WPA -3.7

Week 5 vs Arizona Cardinals

  1. Q1 13:084th & 17 at the own 24 · tied · Punted, punt 49 ydscalc: punted · go 42% / punt 48% · WPA +4.4
  2. Q1 03:464th & 13 at the own 23 · down 7 · Punted, punt 57 ydscalc: punted · go 24% / punt 25% · WPA +2.6
  3. Q1 00:284th & 9 at the ARI 42 · down 7 · Punted, punt 29 ydscalc: field goal · go 29% / punt 29% / fg 31% · WPA +0.6
  4. Q2 13:374th & 3 at the ARI 47 · down 7 · Went for it, convertedcalc: went for it · go 29% / punt 28% / fg 27% · WPA +10.2
  5. Q2 09:384th & 1 at the ARI 38 · tied · Went for it, touchdowncalc: went for it · go 57% / punt 49% / fg 54% · WPA +17.2
  6. Q2 04:554th & 4 at the ARI 8 · up 7 · Went for it, touchdowncalc: field goal · go 74% / punt 71% / fg 80% · WPA +7.3
  7. Q2 00:574th & 7 at the ARI 27 · up 14 · Field goal, madecalc: went for it · go 93% / punt 63% / fg 91% · WPA +0.2
  8. Q3 01:074th & 1 at the ARI 1 · up 17 · Went for it, touchdowncalc: went for it · go 97% / punt 97% / fg 97% · WPA +1.5
  9. Q4 00:344th & 5 at the own 33 · up 24 · Punted, punt 65 ydscalc: went for it · go 100% / punt 100% · WPA 0.0

Week 7 vs Green Bay Packers

  1. Q2 12:404th & 7 at the GB 22 · tied · Field goal, madecalc: field goal · go 54% / punt 49% / fg 57% · WPA +2.3
  2. Q2 09:264th & 17 at the own 38 · up 3 · Punted, touchbackcalc: punted · go 52% / punt 58% · WPA -0.7
  3. Q3 01:094th & 5 at the GB 6 · up 3 · Went for it, failedcalc: went for it · go 91% / punt 61% / fg 73% · WPA -11.2
  4. Q4 13:514th & 9 at the own 44 · up 3 · Punted, punt 42 ydscalc: punted · go 63% / punt 64% · WPA -2.9
  5. Q4 04:534th & 1 at the own 24 · tied · Went for it, failedcalc: went for it · go 45% / punt 45% · WPA -12.6

Week 8 vs Minnesota Vikings

  1. Q1 09:354th & 23 at the MIN 49 · tied · Punted, punt 39 ydscalc: punted · go 48% / punt 50% / fg 47% · WPA +0.9
  2. Q1 02:214th & 5 at the MIN 7 · tied · Field goal, madecalc: went for it · go 59% / punt 48% / fg 56% · WPA +0.2
  3. Q2 06:454th & 3 at the own 26 · down 4 · Punted, punt 53 ydscalc: punted · go 32% / punt 33% · WPA +4.1
  4. Q2 03:174th & 9 at the 50 · down 4 · Punted, punt 40 ydscalc: punted · go 33% / punt 36% / fg 32% · WPA +3.9
  5. Q3 09:544th & 5 at the MIN 28 · down 1 · Field goal, missedcalc: field goal · go 52% / punt 5% / fg 52% · WPA -13.3
  6. Q4 12:484th & 5 at the own 30 · up 5 · Punted, punt 54 ydscalc: punted · go 65% / punt 72% · WPA +4.9

Era tracker

Dan Campbell, head coach since 2021. Regular season 53-38-1, postseason 2-2; one-score games 27-23-1; as favorite 42-13, as underdog 13-27-1; division 21-11.

SeasonRegPostOne-scoreDivision
20213-13-1—2-6-12-4
20229-8—4-55-1
202312-52-17-44-2
202415-20-17-26-0
20259-8—3-52-4
20265-2—4-12-0

In his words